Visual novel review: Fate/hollow ataraxia


I was always planning to try doing visual novel reviews on my blog. I figured Fate/hollow ataraxia would be a good title to start with considering I only finished it recently, and it helped me come up with the name of my blog in the first place. Anyone who has been reading my blog may have noticed that my anime reviews haven’t really been that great, but part of the reason for me to start blogging in the first place was to improve my writing so hopefully there will be some noticeable improvement soon. I tried to keep this review free of spoilers as much as possible, so feel free to read without worrying about spoilers.

Fate/hollow ataraxia is a visual novel by Type-Moon, it is the fandisk/sequel to the popular Fate/stay night. It was originally released on PC in 2005, and was recently ported to PS Vita in November, 2014. Like Fate/stay night, the main game for the most part has the text presented in a way that reads much like a normal novel. I’m a pretty big Type-Moon fan, at the moment it’s probably my favourite franchise so I’m not going to pretend this review might be a bit biased. I really like Nasu Kinoko’s writing style and I find it easily helps me immerse myself in the story and the world in which it is set.


Fate/hollow ataraxia starts off 6 months after the Heaven’s Feel (holy grail war) from Fate/stay night ended. It seems to be set in an alternate timeline to the Fate, Unlimited Blade Works, and Heaven’s Feel routes though. The setting has similarities and references to all three routes from Fate/stay night.

The story starts with the Heaven’s Feel being restarted, Bazett Fraga McRemitz gets sent by the Mages’ Association to be their representative with her servant, from the Avenger class. Emiya Shirou is living peacefully in his house and all the servants from Fate/stay night are still alive, no one seems particularly interested in fighting in the restarted Heaven’s Feel. Kotomine Kirei is dead and a replacement is at the church to oversee the Heaven’s Feel.

There is a time loop, a four day period where everything resets during the night before the fifth day. The story is either told from Avenger’s point of view or from Shirou’s. Shirou tries to investigate why the Heaven’s Feel has been restarted while Avenger works with Bazett to try and win the Heaven’s Feel before the fifth day.

The time loop makes it really easy to 100% the game, because whatever choice you make, you can always come back and choose the other option during the next loop.

H scenes

There is only one sex scene in the main story, Caren Ortensia is the main heroine and her sex scene is honestly really good. I generally don’t really care much for sex scenes in visual novels, when sex scenes appear, it often comes across feeling forced and unnecessary. Caren’s sex scene doesn’t feel this way at all, in fact, it is very important to the story. If you’re the type of person who will skip sex scenes when you can, I would highly recommend not skipping this one.

There are also sex scenes for the three heroines from Fate/stay night. When they are unlocked, you can view them from a section called Eclipse from the main menu. There’s nothing really special about them, but they managed to portray a similar mood and feeling from the character’s respective sex scenes from Fate/stay night.


Because of the four day time loop, there are a lot of scenarios which don’t directly progress the main story. The characters are always entertaining when interacting with each other but it can get a bit tedious with all of the comedy and slice-of-life sections. Not to say that those are bad, most of them are really good. Just comparing them to the more serious parts which actually progress with the story makes them seem less interesting in comparison.

Some of the servants have more information about their past lives revealed and clarified during Fate/hollow ataraxia, mainly Lancer and Rider. Also reveals more information about what happened during Fate/zero



Unfortunately, there is no voice patch for Fate/hollow ataraxia like there was for Fate/stay night. Hopefully one day someone manages to extract the voice files from the recent PS Vita release and inserts it into the PC version. Although I didn’t notice most of the time because in my head all the characters were speaking with the voices they used in their respective anime that they appeared in.

The soundtrack I don’t think was very memorable, but it did a good job of portraying the right atmosphere for the situations.

EDIT: I recently looked at the Beast’s Lair forums and noticed that a voice insertion project has been started. Someone has taken it upon himself to manually record all the voiced lines from the Vita version. I’m looking forward to when this is completed, I’ll definitely be re-reading through at least the main story again to hear it voiced.


There are a few mini-games in Fate/hollow ataraxia. A collection of arcade style games at Illya’s castle, as well as a Hanafuda card game, where you play as different master/servant pairs and defeat the other master/servants to gain access to a magical hot spring. There are some CGs to unlock by progressing though the mini-games, but they aren’t really necessary so you can stop if you get bored.


Overall impressions

I personally enjoyed this game a lot. There wasn’t as much serious parts as there were in Fate/stay night, but it was still a great experience reading through everything during the better part of a week. I hope one day they make an anime series or a movie out of it.

Final score: 8.5/10


About FabledHunter

Novice Anime Blogger.

Posted on January 28, 2015, in Reviews and Impressions, Visual Novels and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink. 8 Comments.

  1. I always wanted to play a visual novel but I’m pretty skeptical about how good the overall media is. I tried playing Clannad before (why the heck did I try that?) but it seemed very draggy so I stopped. Could you suggest me any good visual novel for me?


    • Well there’s a massive range. There are many different types of visual novel so you have to take into consideration what you are looking for. Things like genre, game length, amount of adult content (if any), linear vs branching plot, etc.

      It ultimately comes down to whether you want to invest a massive amount of time into reading or not. Most visual novels I play take longer than 50 hours to finish, which is a lot of time compared to anime (for example, your standard 2-cour anime only has ~8 hours of content.)

      Recommending something when I don’t know what you are looking for is a bit hard, and I’ve only finished ~15 visual novels myself so the range I have to recommend visual novels I’ve personally played is fairly limited.

      I did give my brother three visual novels to try out once and the only one he finished is Umineko, so that might be good for beginners. It doesn’t have any decisions so you can’t really get lost like in Clannad. Other games that might be easy to start off with might be Rewrite, it’s by the same people who made Clannad, but I think it is easier to keep interest and not get lost. Also G-senjou no Maou, it’s shorter than the other two and has a linear plot for the most part, (one true end, with the other heroines having their route as an ending branching off from the main story).

      vndb links for above mentioned VNs:
      Umineko –
      Rewrite –
      G-senjou no Maou –

      If you have any other questions about visual novels or want different recommendations feel free to ask. I will help as much as I can.


      • I guess I’ll try G-senjou no Maou since it’s shorter. Though, I think I’l remove the H scenes / nudity because I’m not really a fan of it (I’m underage). One question, do we need to play from the beginning to know other story arcs? If so, it’ll be tiresome and time consuming.


        • For G-senjou no Maou there aren’t many choices, when it gives the same choice twice, that’s when it branches out to the other characters’ arcs. No you don’t need to read everything from the beginning for the other story arcs, you can either load a save from just before it or just skip through previously read text until you get to the decision.

          Also remember if you aren’t enjoying it don’t feel forced to finishing it, don’t be like me where I watch terrible anime just for the sake of completing it. There’s no point in wasting time on something you aren’t enjoying.

          Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved the Fate/Stay Night visual novel and I’ve been meaning for ages to start Hollow Ataraxia as well. Which do you think is the better VN?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: